Kate Forbes speaking at a conference podium with the word HOPE on it. She has long brown hair and wears a red dress.

Dear Kate, Scotland doesn’t need to be saved by “Biblical truths”

Joe Higgins, Policy and Campaigns Officer

June 29, 2026

Our Policy and Campaigns Officer Joe Higgins on Kate Forbes’s comments at the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship conference organised by Jordan Peterson.

In case you missed it, on 25 June Kate Forbes, the former deputy first minister, spoke at a conference co-organised by the right-wing academic Jordan Peterson, dubbed “the anti-woke Davos”. Also in attendance were members of the Trump administration, Reform UK MPs, and the evangelical lobbying group Alliance Defending Freedom.

Kate used her speech to rail against secularism. She claimed that the values of “freedom, liberty, human dignity, the worth of life, and flourishing for all” were, in fact, “Biblical concepts”. And she decried the side-lining of voices of faith in western politics, particularly during the assisted dying debate.

Hands holding a bible.

Kate’s assertion that only people of faith hold an ‘inner conscience guided by historical truths’ does not stand up to any kind of scrutiny

What should humanists make of Kate’s newfound candour? Needless to say, the values of human dignity, freedom, and liberty aren’t the preserve of the bible. These are universal human values that transcend established religions and life stances. Nor does Kate’s assertion that only people of faith hold an “inner conscience guided by historical truths” stand up to any kind of scrutiny.

All of us are guided by a moral framework, whether this is based on divine commands or on reason, empathy, and shared values like justice, fairness, and respect for the autonomy of others. Moreover, it is right to question whether the “biblical values” Forbes espouses would be realised if her theological interpretations regarding gender, same-sex marriage, pre-marital sex, and abortion were adopted by the state. 

An LGBT Pride March in Scotland.

Kate cannot pretend that, if her beliefs were put into practice, the fundamental rights and freedoms of others would face no consequence.

Once upon a time, Scotland was a much more socially conservative country. At that time, views like Kate Forbes’s were much more mainstream. The result was fewer freedoms and less respect for the autonomy and dignity of women and LGBT+ people. Kate Forbes is entitled to hold and express her beliefs, religious or otherwise. Indeed, as humanists, we will always defend her right to do so. But she can’t claim that those views are simply ‘a matter of conscience’ and beyond reproach because they are grounded in faith.

Seven people standing in front of some railings holding up placards with captions like "WOMEN DO REGRET ABORTION".
AN EXAMLPE OF A NOW ILLEGAL “PRAYER VIGIL” OUTSIDE AN ABORTION CLINIC IN EDINBURGH

Some of Forbes’s supporters like to point out that her personal views are irrelevant to her policy agenda because they refer to “settled issues” of bodily autonomy and human rights. This is dangerously naive.

Nor can Kate pretend that, if her beliefs were put into practice, the fundamental rights and freedoms of others would face no consequence. Politicians seek power and influence because they have aspirations for a better society, grounded in their views, experiences, and beliefs. Kate Forbes is no different, and her appearance at ARC 2026 is a clear and worrying indication of her vision for our country.

Some of Forbes’s supporters like to point out that her personal views are irrelevant to her policy agenda because they refer to “settled issues” of bodily autonomy and human rights. This is dangerously naive. Let’s take abortion as an example. Even setting aside the threat of regression as we’ve seen abroad, reproductive rights in Scotland are still far from where they should be.

Women and pregnant people are still forced to travel to England to access their legal right to abortion care. Timely and accessible abortion services remain a postcode lottery. And the final decision to end a pregnancy still sits with two doctors, no matter the gestational stage. The idea that a pro-life First Minister could be expected to both defend the status-quo against international backlash to reproductive freedoms and meaningfully improve women’s access to abortion care is for the birds. 

It’s no surprise to hear Kate Forbes defending Christian evangelism while flanked by the new forces of illiberalism in global politics. But it is chilling, nonetheless. We, as a nation, must have a long and frank discussion should she ever seek a return to mainstream politics in Scotland.

Support our campaign work, make a donation today

Our campaign work is funded by the generous support of our members and supporters. Support our campaign work and help to create a fairer Scotland and world.

Cartoon showing a person dropping a coin into a collection box.

Join us!

Your membership will help to fund our campaign work to make Scotland a more secular, rational, and socially just country, and to ensure everyone in Scotland has access to humanist ceremonies to mark important life events.

Cartoon showing a group of protestors outside Holyrood holding up placards and carrying loudspeakers

All images Wikipedia/CC.

Latest Related Stories

Kate Forbes speaking on a stage wearing a teal dress.

Kate Forbes speaks at “anti-woke Davos”, calls for defence of Judeo-Christian values as basis of democracy

Kate Forbes speaks at “anti-woke Davos”, calls for defence of Judeo-Christian values as basis of democracy
Picture of Leon, who has brown hair in curtains and wears a black jacket. He smiles to a point just off camera.

Humanist Society interview series: Leon Langdon of Humanists International on Christian nationalist money in our politics

Humanist Society interview series: Leon Langdon of Humanists International on Christian nationalist money in our politics

Majority of MSPs choose secular affirmation in Holyrood first

Majority of MSPs choose secular affirmation in Holyrood first

Election 2026: School worship opt-out a key priority in children’s rights manifesto

Election 2026: School worship opt-out a key priority in children’s rights manifesto