Vic Valentine addresses a pro-trans rights rally infront of a sign asking MSPs to vote for the GRA reform bill. People around them hold placards that read "Trans Rights Now" and they wave trans pride flags.

Humanist Society interviews: Vic Valentine of Scottish Trans Alliance

March 31, 2023

Today, 31 March 2023, is International Trans Day of Visibility. Humanist Society Scotland has a long relationship with Scotland’s LGBT+ communities and the last 12 months have been significant and trying ones for trans people in Scotland. Holyrood passed a bill that would have made gender recognition easier and more dignified for trans men and women and non-binary people in Scotland. But the legislation was blocked from becoming law at Westminster, the first time the UK government has ever utilised their power in this way.

Vic Valentine is a Policy Officer at the Equality Network. Vic works on the Scottish Trans Alliance project and was a big part of the push for GRA reform. So, we thought Vic would be a great person to talk to to find out more about the joys and challenges of being trans in Scotland, and where next for the movement for trans equality.

Can you tell us a bit about yourself and how you became passionate about trans rights?

I’m a non-binary trans person, so in many ways it was somewhat selfishly motivated! But the thing that got me particularly invested in making a difference was when I was working at a LGBTQ+ mental health charity in Brighton and seeing the huge range of ways in which trans people were being let down. Whether that was through inadequate housing, lack of safety on the streets, or mental health services that couldn’t seem to understand that sometimes being trans was the part of someone’s life that they were most confident and happy with, not the thing that was the problem.

Can you tell us a bit about the Scottish Trans Alliance and how you got involved?

Scottish Trans is a project at the Equality Network, a lesbian, gay, bi, trans and intersex equality and human rights charity. Our day-to-day work is all about making Scotland a better place for trans people. We mostly do this by working with trans people and communities, figuring out what’s going on for us and what we need to live better lives, and then translating that into work with policy and decision-makers to let them know how they could be doing things differently. The idea is to remove the barriers and difficulties we might be facing.

We also campaign, particularly when it comes to legal changes. Obviously for the last number of years that has focused on reforming the Gender Recognition Act.

A large crowd at Pride Scotia 2014: lots of balloons and a Nae Nazis sign are visible.
Photo Stephen Yu/Creative Commons

Mental health services couldn’t seem to understand that sometimes being trans was the part of someone’s life that they were most confident and happy with, not the thing that was the problem.

Vic Valentine, Scottish Trans Alliance

What should readers know about the GRA reform bill that recently passed through Holyrood?

It would have made the process for trans men and women to update the sex recorded on their birth certificate to reflect who they truly are a much simpler and fairer one. Currently, you have to submit a psychiatric diagnosis of gender dysphoria and medical reports to a tribunal of doctors and judges who decide whether you can change it. You also have to wait two years from when you’ve started permanently living as who you know are before you can apply. That means you can be stuck for a period with totally mismatching documents, giving you no choice but to share that you’re trans anytime your birth certificate is needed.

Instead, a legal declaration signed by the trans person themselves and witnessed by a notary public would have been used and the time reduced from two years to six months. This would have moved Scotland closer to international best practice. More than 30 places around the world are already using this kind of ‘self-determination’ model.

If people would like to know more about why the law should change, they can check out: “Five reasons to support reforming the Gender Recognition Act”

GRA reform is currently held up because Westminster blocked the passage of the legislation. Where next for the cause? What do Scottish Trans have planned, and what would you like to see happen next?

The crucial thing for us is that people have a fair process they can use to update their birth certificate. In all honesty, it’s hard to know for sure how we get there now. One option is for the Scottish Government to challenge the UK Government’s decision in the Courts and see what they decide. Another is to leave the Bill on the Scottish Parliament’s books and revisit the situation when there is a UK Government which is less hostile to improving trans people’s lives.

The choice on which option to take is one that people with lots more power than us will get to make. But whatever happens, we’ll be working hard to ensure that the voices and perspectives of trans people in Scotland are heard, and keep making the positive case for why this Bill should become law.

But wider than gender recognition reform, there’s still lots more to be done. Our top priority is improving the situation for trans people trying to access gender identity services. Waiting lists are counted in years and we think services are far too reliant on psychiatrists when they don’t need to be. It’s vital that there is investment and care poured into these services so that trans people can access timely, high quality care – as we all should be able to!

Support our campaign work, make a donation today

Our campaign work is funded by the generous support of our members and supporters. Support our campaign work and help to create a fairer Scotland and world.

Handwriting a letter

Join us!

Your membership will help to fund our campaign work to make Scotland a more secular, rational, and socially just country, and to ensure everyone in Scotland has access to humanist ceremonies to mark important life events.

Two people in a conference crowd laughing

Latest Related Stories

Fraser Sutherland address a crowd (not visible) from a podium wearing a blue suit and green tweed tie against a purple wall. He has short brown hair and his hands opened as if to clarify a point.

Our CEO interviewed in The National on religious rep education votes

Our CEO interviewed in The National on religious rep education votes
An image of Gemma leaning against a concrete waymarker, probably on a mountain walk, on a foggy day. She smiles at the camera, has died auburn hair and a maroon jacket.

Humanist Society interviews: Gemma Clark

Humanist Society interviews: Gemma Clark
An image of Auldearn Primary School near Nairn, a stone building with large windows and a slate roof, flanked by pine trees and with a highland landscape in the background.

Highland Council removes votes from religious representatives on education committee

Highland Council removes votes from religious representatives on education committee
A portrait shot of Greg McHugh. He wears a blue shirt and has short brown hair. He smiles at the camera

Humanist Society interviews: Greg McHugh

Humanist Society interviews: Greg McHugh