Letter from Prof Rebecca Stott

January 31, 2019

Exclusive Brethren sues Scottish academic over publication of sermons

Dear Scottish Humanists,

I am hoping you might be able to help support a dear friend of mine, Ian McKay, a 74-year-old academic from Glasgow who is defending himself against a relentless campaign of ‘vexatious litigation’ from a group of fundamentalist Christians called the Exclusive Brethren (they now call themselves the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church).

Ian was a friend of my late father’s. He helped me find the courage to write my memoir about growing up inside the Brethren. Very few ex-Brethren are able to talk about their experiences because of the psychological control the Brethren instil in their children. (In the Days of Rain: A Daughter, A Father, A Cult won the Costa prize for biography in 2017 – I’ll be giving a reading from the book and a Q&A in Edinburgh at the Humanist Society Conference on May 17th – please join me by booking your place here).

The Brethren are so litigious that my publishers insisted on employing three libel teams. Brethren lawyers have left me alone as a consequence but they are currently suing or threatening to sue everyone who has ever said anything critical about them in the press or on ex-Brethren fora on the internet.

Vexatious litigation, as you will know, is a strategy used to silence people. If you can keep the case open for as long as possible (like the Jarndyce and Jarndyce case in Dickens’ Bleak House) then your enemy will have to agree to your terms or go bankrupt or have a breakdown.

Ian is now 14 months into the horrible experience and there is no sign that the Brethren intend to let up. What are they accusing him of? Publishing short extracts from their preachings. They have charitable status and receive millions of pounds of public subsidy via tax breaks every year but they are taking Ian to court for quoting from their preachings.

The Times and the Sydney Herald have covered Ian’s case in the last week. His friends are exploring every way they can to support him. We have raised £17,000 so far but Ian is likely to need £100,000 to stay afloat. If you can donate we’d be grateful. If you have ideas about other large potential funding bodies who might help, do write to me at rebecca@rebeccastott.co.uk

Here’s the link to the donation page:

https://uk.gofundme.com/Ian-McKay-defence-against-religious-extremist

Best wishes and thank you for reading this,

Rebecca Stott (Professor)

Latest Related Stories

The Danish Parliament building at Christiansborg, with multi-storey stone wings and a central spire.

Our CEO talks Danish blasphemy laws on BBC Scotland

Our CEO talks Danish blasphemy laws on BBC Scotland
An image of Gemma leaning against a concrete waymarker, probably on a mountain walk, on a foggy day. She smiles at the camera, has died auburn hair and a maroon jacket.

Humanist Society interview series: Gemma Clark, abortion rights campaigner

Humanist Society interview series: Gemma Clark, abortion rights campaigner
An image of the Scottish Parliament building at Holyrood with Calton Hill and the city of Edinburgh in the background.

Our priorities for Humza Yousaf

Our priorities for Humza Yousaf
Joe Goldblatt profile portrait. Joe wears a black suit and has a shiny stripy tie and finely striped blue shirt. He wears glasses and has blonde hair worn back on his head. He smiles warmly at the camera.

Humanist Society interview series: Joe Goldblatt of Interfaith Edinburgh

Humanist Society interview series: Joe Goldblatt of Interfaith Edinburgh