The Scottish Parliament debating chamber

Religious freedom group in Parliament claims ‘Christian persecution’

October 1, 2015

by Gary McLelland

A new Cross-Party Group has been established in The Scottish Parliament to promote ‘religious freedom’. Several MSPs have joined the Group; Dave Thompson (SNP), Chair of Christians for Independence, and a prominent campaigner against Equal Marriage, has been named as the Group’s Convener; Michael McMahon (Lab) and Anne McTaggart (Lab) have been jointly named the Group’s Co-convener; with Murdo Fraser (Con) and John Mason (SNP) also listed as members.

In a recent podcast David Andrew Robertson, Director of SOLAS, one of the founding members of this Group, explained that the establishment of the Group is a direct response to ‘atheistic secularists’.

It’s also worth noting that four of the five MSP members opposed Equal Marriage, and three of the five members recently supported a motion in The Scottish Parliament that said that “…some people believe that God created the world in six days […] none of these positions can be proved or disproved by science and all are valid beliefs for people to hold…”.

The first problem with this new Group is the fact that it raises one particular world-view, the religious one, above all others. There is not doubt that religious people face persecution in many parts of the world, although this is invariably of a sectarian nature, rather than anti-religious bigotry. However, by specifically focussing on ‘religious freedom’, rather than ‘freedom of religion and belief’, this group has alienated around 1-in-2 people in Scotland, who according to the latest Scottish Household Attitudes Survey.

There are other reasons to be concerned about this new group, looking at some of the organisations listed as members, there are a new interesting thing which emerge:

There are 18 organisations which have signed up as members of the group, 15 are Christian, one Jewish, one Muslim and one Interfaith. Despite around half of people in Scotland having no religion, there was no attempt to contact Humanist Society Scotland which has over 14,000 members.

One theme which emerges from many of the organisations involved with this new group is the erroneous trope that Christians in the UK are being persecuted, or ‘excluded’ from the public sphere.

The truth is that Christian groups, and other religious groups, continue to enjoy significant legal, cultural and political privileges in Scotland and the UK. Take for example the recent comments by former Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond when he said that he ‘prefers people of faith’.

There is also the many privileges that religious groups enjoy in the state-funded education system, such as free seats on local authority education committees, the legal right to discriminate in staff recruitment and pupil selection, not to mention the over-representation of religious people in the Scottish Parliament’s Time for Reflection slots.

Clearly any group which is serious about promoting the vitally important rights to freedom of religion, belief and conscience needs to look out beyond its own narrow religious horizons.

Latest Related Stories

A view of the Human Rights and Alliance of Civilizations Room at the UN headquarters in Geneva. Circular rows of desks are arranged on the floor but most of the picture is taken up by the ceiling artwork, a textured sculpture in a blue, green, orange, and yellow colour wash with stalactite like formations handing down from it.

We tell UN human rights committee that compulsory religious observance in Scottish schools must end

We tell UN human rights committee that compulsory religious observance in Scottish schools must end
Brian Souter gesticulates with his arms as he speaks. He is wearing a blue suit with a stagecoach logo and has short brown hair, balding on top.

We comment on Humza Yousaf’s relationship with evangelical businessman Brian Souter, funder of US-based organisations alleged to have covered up sexual assault in US

We comment on Humza Yousaf’s relationship with evangelical businessman Brian Souter, funder of US-based organisations alleged to have covered up sexual assault in US
Alice stands on a street wearing a white dress with leather jacket. She has dark pulled back hair and holds her hand to her head. A scottish street stretches away in the background.

Humanist Society interview series: Alice Murray of Back Off Scotland on abortion clinic harassment

Humanist Society interview series: Alice Murray of Back Off Scotland on abortion clinic harassment
Recep Erdogan speaks into a microphone at a press event infront of a blue backdrop with large white text on it (illegible). He has short greying black hair swept to one side and a moustache. He wears a blue suit and tie.

Humanist Society speaks out on Humza Yousaf’s invitation to Scotland for Recep Erdoğan

Humanist Society speaks out on Humza Yousaf’s invitation to Scotland for Recep Erdoğan