Scottish humanists challenge religious leaders on assisted suicide

January 27, 2015

    Today (27th January) the Scottish Parliament’s Health and Sport Committee
    will take evidence from a range of religious leaders, many of whom Humanist
    Society Scotland says are out of touch with the actual views and beliefs of
    their members. Humanist Society Scotland challenges religious objections to the
    Assisted Suicide (Scotland) Bill.

    Under the 2010 Equality Act, religion and belief are to be treated equally.
    Despite this, the Scottish Parliament’s Health and Sport Committee has decided
    to take evidence from a panel made up of religious leaders separately from other
    secular organisations, like Humanist Society Scotland.

    A 2013 survey (BMJ 2013;346:f2897) on assisted suicide found that the
    attitudes of members of certain religious groups was significantly out of step
    with the official position of that religion. The survey found that 61% of
    Presbyterians (such as the Church of Scotland) were in favour of assisted
    suicide; 56% of Catholics and 72% of Anglicans also supported a change in the
    law to allow terminally ill people to end their own lives.

    In the same survey, it was found that less than 0.02% of respondents said
    that they look to religious leaders for guidance on assisted suicide, versus 65%
    who said they look to science and their own reason and intuition.

    Commenting on the day’s proceedings, Ian Scott (acting chief executive of
    Humanist Society Scotland) said:

    “It’s widely accepted now that leaders of many religious groups do not
    accurately reflect the views of their members. We want to make sure that our
    politicians are fully aware that these appointed religious leaders do not
    necessarily reflect the views and beliefs of the significant minority of Scots
    who are religious.

    “Across a range of contemporary moral issues we find that the vast
    majority of Scots put evidence, compassion and empathy first – and this approach
    is much more in line with a humanistic worldview.

    “The simple fact is that most religious people support these measures,
    and whilst religious leaders have a right to speak on these matters, MSPs must
    be aware that their views are not necessarily representative.”

    Latest Related Stories

    A group of young people laugh and chat over their laptop screens. They are around 15-16 and dressed in casual clothes.

    We launch our new education guides for non-religious young people, parents, and carers

    We launch our new education guides for non-religious young people, parents, and carers
    Three horizontally aligned images show activities for World Humanist Day. There are people serving a range of world foods from a long table to the left, part of the Pollokshields event. In the centre are cubscouts designing community gardens with pen and paper on the floor of their scout hut. To the right is a group of humanists on a walk in Edinburgh at the foot of Salisbury Crags.

    Looking back on World Humanist Day

    Looking back on World Humanist Day

    Membership fee increases August 2023

    Membership fee increases August 2023
    Fraser Sutherland stands at a lectern addressing a room of people, some of whom are visible behind him, as the crowd spreads in a circle round the speaker's stand. He wears a blue suit and red tie and has short brown hair.

    On World Humanist Day 2023, we have more to fight for than ever

    On World Humanist Day 2023, we have more to fight for than ever